Monday, March 24, 2008

Supplementary vote is neither proportional nor radical

Backing a plan to bring in supplementary vote (having a first and second preference in an election) is hardly radical, as Jack Straw and the government seem to think. Supplementary vote suffers from many of the problems moving away from first-past-the-post should intend to avoid - many ballots will not be counted (in FPTP, any votes not for the top two parties are largely irrelevant; in SV, votes not for the three most popular are largely irrelevant). A huge number of votes are effectively wasted.

What would be radical is a move towards a fully proportional electoral system - one which elects candidates based on their popularity compared to other candidates (the Condorcet winner). A winner under a Condorcet election would clearly have a mandate being the most popular amongst voters - and there would be more of an incentive to vote honestly as all votes count.

Monday, March 17, 2008

Elected!

I just thought I'd mention that I've been elected as the new Academic Affairs Officer for the University of Manchester Students' Union for the 2008/9 academic year. The post is to represent students, individually and collectively, within the University, to advise students on education/academic issues, and to inform students about education issues.

It's a full-time position, starting in June, and I'm looking forward to it (I have to graduate first though). Both my manifesto (PDF) and a video recording (QuickTime) of me saying what I want to do are available on the Union website.

I aim to have a more active blog starting from June explaining what I have been up to throughout the year in the position!

The results for my position were (the election was conducted under STV):

CandidatesVotes
Chris Jenkinson1225 (1135 + 8 + 82)
Ketan Alder832 (661 + 7 + 164)
Abdul Hannan Ali479 (469 + 10)
Re-Open Nominations79

Tuesday, March 11, 2008

Sour grapes from the SWP

Not able to gracefully admit defeat, learn the lessons and move on, several members of the Socialist Workers' Party at the University of Manchester have started attacking students for democratically booting them out. Dave Sewell, one of the few SWP members who will be on Union council next year has written a rather bitter message attacking students for "not being intelligent enough" to vote for SWP candidates.

As I've come to expect from members of the SWP, the blog allows no open debate - only "approved" messages will be displayed, so I'm reproducing what I wrote here (for the record, anyone can reply here and the messages will appear straight away):

This really is a load of bitter rubbish. Also, I’m surprised to note a substantial lack of criticism of myself - perhaps trying to get away with calling the Lib Dems pro-tuition fees is a lie too far even for the SWP?

“I say lost; politically, the victory was very much ours. When we got out talking to people, in interminable nights trawling the halls of residence and in countless lecture announcements, we would almost always come out with a hugely positive response.”

I got a positive response as well when giving lecture shout-outs, and when talking to students both in halls and on campus. By your logic I won the argument politically as well!

People I spoke to were annoyed with several of this year’s executive and the majority of last year’s sole focus on international issues, leaving them stranded when the University started cutting contact hours, began ‘teaching’ online rather than face-to-face, and closing departmental libraries. That happened when the SWP controlled the Union and look where that got Manchester’s students.

“Some positions were contested by non-Labour candidates, and many of these shamelessly mimicked our rhetoric, promising a fighting union and a free education, all the while conterfactually deriding the potential for radical mass action in favour of engaging with politicians individually.”

I think you’ll find there was just one sabbatical position contested by Labour Students.

In case this is referring to me, I’m afraid that just because one group of people believe something does not mean that other people cannot believe it either. I believe in a free education, so saying that I was “shamelessly mimicking [your] rhetoric” is entirely inaccurate.

Do you not think that we should talk to elected MPs then? Perhaps this is why last year’s executive didn’t achieve anything other than annoying students. I think that talking, debating and arguing with people who actually get to decide whether there will be a free education is a more effective tactic than attempting to overthrow them in a revolution.

“Needless to say, this was a crushing defeat. Although votes haven’t been counted for all the minor positions yet, it looks like the Left will have gone from a position of hegemony to holding just two insignificant posts on the Council (one of them by none other than myself, touch wood) and none on the Executive. The ruling party now control the students’ union that was most expected to challenge their policies next year, and the zionists now control the union with one of the most advanced campaigns for solidarity with Palestine. The implications could hardly be more stark. It hurts on a personal level too. To expend so much energy on what turned out to be a defeat felt like running an uphill marathon to the edge of some massive cliff with Sonic-the-Hedgehog metal spikes at the bottom and not stopping in time.”

The Labour party and the “zionists” control the Students’ Union!? I’m not sure that one out of eight sabbatical officers counts as “controlling”. There are twice as many Green sabbatical officers than Labour Students, but obviously people related to Jews must be Zionist (oh look, I’m Zionist too, and so’s Chomsky!).

“one thing I can guarantee - they haven’t heard the last of us!”

No, students won’t have heard the last of you, because this year we will be turning the Students’ Union around and show how much better it is when it engages with students. When officers are supported by the Union rather than restricted by its rules, when students can communicate and engage with the Union, when the Union delivers results on issues care about, we will be reminding people just how awful the Union was in the days of the SWP, so new students will never make the same mistake again.

Sunday, February 03, 2008

Don't ride Stagecoach

The public transport company Stagecoach, including one of its brandnames Magic Bus, dominate the student-heavy Oxford Road bus route in Manchester. Unfortunately Stagecoach isn't a nice friendly company providing low-cost, environmentally-friendly public transport that students might assume, as it is owned by a man named Brian Souter. Brian Souter is well-known for donating between £500,000 and £1,000,000 to run a corrupt polling exercise in his (failed) attempt to stop the repeal of Section 28, a homophobic piece of legislation which, among other things, set back over 10 years attempts to tackle homophobic bullying in schools.

In addition, Stagecoach's employees appear to have a culture of homophobia, with a gay couple being thrown off a bus in Aberdeen and a gay employee in Manchester recently made complaints about anti-gay comments going unchallenged by senior staff. Queer Up North have called for a boycott of the company until the company's behaviour changes.

Not only does Stagecoach have a shameful attitude towards LGBT people, but Brian Souter paid himself over £1m in bonuses last year despite the massive rises in fare prices (usually blamed on "rising oil prices"). The company is a disgrace and people should avoid it as much as possible.

For students on the Oxford Road corridor, Finglands is 10p cheaper per single. It is also possible to get a free ride between the Royal Infirmary and North Campus (a short walk from the city centre). Please avoid Stagecoach, and join the group on Facebook calling for a boycott.

Sunday, December 02, 2007

Time for No Platform to end

Stand up for free speech. If you're a delegate to the NUS extraordinary conference, join the Facebook group in opposition to the No Platform policy. If you're not - join and ask your delegates to do the same. If you're a student in Manchester, vote in the priorities ballot on Monday and rank Motion C ("Kicking the racists off our campuses") last. There is just one way to defeat fascism and racism - freedom for all.
One of the useful things about complete overhauls is that nothing is sacred. The proposed NUS constitution is attempting to enshrine the illiberal "no platform" policy (banning those the NUS leadership think are racists from attending NUS events and preventing NUS officials from debating them), in effect making it all but impossible to ever remove the no platform policy. The conference on Tuesday 4th December is the one and only chance to stand up for free speech and show that it is far more effective to engage in debate and defeat extremists, as shown at the Oxford Union last week. This seems to have gone under the radar during the massive debate about whether the NUS governance review promotes or limits democracy - but it is absolutely certain that any organisation which can ban an elected delegate from speaking their mind is far from democratic.

In a liberal and democratic society, all must be free to voice their opinions in public. A marketplace of ideas is how society has progressed from an autocratic theocracy in the times of Galileo (the apocryphal muttering of "and yet it moves") through the Enlightenment to the generally free culture we live in today. It is open debate, with rigorous scrutiny of ideas, which leads to advancement of our society. Some ideas are right, and some are wrong - it is open scrutiny and honest debate which allows us to determine which is which. Unfortunately, it is not possible to realistically distinguish between inoffensive ideas, offensive ideas which are beneficial, and offensive ideas which are just offensive. Today, someone without an understanding of religious history would not understand why, 500 years ago, the theory of heliocentrism would have led to persecution for those that suggested the theory, and the offense such an idea caused. They might also not understand why the theory of evolution is rejected and those that publically accept it in certain regions of the world are ostracised from their families and communities. Both of these theories have been seen as offensive - but they are beneficial because they have turned out to be right.

The BNP have undergone a PR review to make them appear less extreme to the public, changing policies like repatriation of non-white people from compulsory to "voluntary with incentives". This is offensive, and is almost certainly nothing more than just racism. But to cut off the BNP's right to state offensive ideas, just because they are offensive, would logically lead to the banning, in some institutions of correct academic ideas like evolution, as it is offensive. It is moral relativism (i.e. hypocrisy) to limit free speech on the grounds it is offensive at home while campaigning for human rights and civil liberties abroad when it is freedom of speech - the freedom to offend - which has been the key freedom in the development of the society we have today. The BNP must be given the rope to hang themselves.

Finally, the claim is made that by debating with members of the BNP they views are legitimised. Utter rubbish - in a debate one side wins and the other loses. A loss in a debate is a sign that one's views are not legitimate. If people think that Nick Griffin being humiliated and embarrassed by a student half his age is legitimising the BNP, they're talking nonsense.

Tuesday, November 20, 2007

Walkouts

If you don't want a motion to be debated or passed at a meeting, is it right to walk out of a meeting so that it no longer has quorum? I would generally say no, but on the other hand, is it right that turning up to vote "no" may actually lead to the motion being passed (cf. the monotonicity criterion - voting against something should not make it more likely to occur)?

Sunday, November 11, 2007

Smashing barriers - improving Union Council

The University of Manchester Student Union's Council is an interesting contraption; it's frequently criticised as being rather pointless. The obvious question is why is it pointless? I am going to attempt to answer that question, and propose some solutions. That question can be broken down.

Is Council pointless:
- because of its structure?
- because of its power/responsibilities?
- because it has few resources?
- because of its current members?

First of all, what is Council and why does it currently exist? The constitution defines Council as "sole representative of the student body of the University in all matters". It has control of the Union's property, and premises used by the Union, is responsible for the Union's management, can bring legal proceedings, it oversees societies, and can borrow money. It can pass motions which are binding on the Union. That is quite a broad remit.

So why, at our last Council meeting, were the two motions discussed, while important, rather lacking in ambition and scope? Why weren't any (if they were questions asked, they weren't particularly memorable) questions asked to the Executive? If students who are actually on Council and therefore are (presumably) interested in the way their Union runs aren't questioning their Executive, how can we expect "ordinary" students to take an interest?

Enough preamble! On with the problems.

Council's structure probably acts as a barrier to ordinary participation. It's on a Tuesday evening, when many societies hold their events, when many students do both academic and paid work, and some decent TV is on. Other than for society events, many students are unlikely to be around on campus. Would a Wednesday afternoon be a better time for Council members and students to attend?

It is only possible to submit written reports, and only executive members can do so (or do so). I believe having executive members giving a brief oral report summarising their written report would act as a way to facilitate more discussion and scrutiny.

In order for something to be discussed at Council, a motion must be proposed. There is no way to have a general discussion about an issue, or to have a non-adversarial debate. Not everything Council does has to be zero-sum.

Ordinary students aren't able to contribute motions. The only way for most students to directly have their say in how the Union operates is at a general meeting, and past experience of general meetings is that only controversial motions get enough people to discuss them, leaving the supporters of uncontroversial motions (like lobbying against cuts in IT services or for environmental issues) out in the cold, meaning it is only with the goodwill of the current Executive that what students want will be done. If ordinary students were able to attend Council and present motions, I imagine the Union would have a lot more policy, and would be far more inclusive.

Is the way Council is formed appropriate? We have four tiers of membership, the Executive, "secretaries" for various positions (including Societies, LGBT, and Education), school representatives, and general members. Is this a good way? Is it fair? Perhaps having titles means that council members feel they can't bring motions in another member's "field".

It might be better to abolish general members and secretaries, and have a proportional number of reps for each faculty or school. While positions like the disabilities or EM secretaries would be lost, they would be replaced with non-sabbatical executive officers for each liberation campaign (who would have responsibilities and a budget). Committees would still exist, just any title-specific role would be replaced by an election to those positions amongst all Council members.

Moving on, I can't see how Council's power or responsibilities limit Council. Council can basically do whatever it likes. But, do Council members know this, and if they do, do they know how to take advantage of it? If the Union had the money, Council could have ordered the purchase of Melbourne University Private (which I think would have been ironic). Is Council's ignorance about what it can do holding it back? Perhaps it is because what Council members aren't formally required to do anything other than attend meetings. I would recommend having formal descriptions of responsibilities for all positions, and making sure Council members can be individually held to account for failing to fulfill responsibilities.

Semi-related, Council would also seem to have all the resources it would need. So why do Council members pick up their agenda just before the meeting? Do people feel that the Union supports them in what they are trying to do? Perhaps the Union should provide more resources to enable Council members to research issues and present them before Council (photocopying, etc.).

Finally, is Council restricted because of its current members? I would say partly - Council meetings are hardly filled with passionate argument and are by no means setting the agenda for students in Manchester or nationally. But I believe that Council members this year would like to do so, but don't feel able to, either because the barriers are due to uncertainty or because of barriers the Union has placed.

We can smash these barriers, but we require a change in both culture and structure.

I would be interested in proposing motions to Council (and constitutional amendments where appropriate) in order to make these changes. Thoughts welcomed.

Saturday, November 03, 2007

Oppose calls for an extraordinary conference

This post is a little on the late side, but must be said anyway.

At last academic year's National Union of Students conference in April, a motion was passed calling for a review of the governance of NUS. The proposed changes are now available. To actually implement the changes, two conferences need to be held, and the document needs to receive a two-thirds majority vote in favour at each one. The NUS leadership realise that many of the suggested changes are quite controversial, so have decided to hold an "extraordinary conference" to try and rush through the changes.

It is rather hypocritical for the NUS leadership to claim that the suggested changes in the governance of NUS increase democracy while at the same time sabotaging democracy by hosting a whole-day event on a Tuesday just a couple of weeks before the begin of the holiday season (a period notorious for coursework deadlines). Because it's an "extraordinary" conference, there is also no requirement that delegates to the conference are democratically elected - they can be appointed by whoever has that responsibility. Furthermore, there are many students' unions across the country which simply cannot afford to pay for their delegates to travel to Blackpool. These student unions will be completely unrepresented (and I suspect will be disproportionately from further education colleges).

How the NUS leadership expect there to be a representative view of student political opinion at the extraordinary conference when so many barriers are put in the way of ordinary students attending is quite beyond me. Oppose the extraordinary conference, make sure your union holds a cross-campus ballot if it can, and make sure your delegates challenge the leadership to explain their anti-democratic methodology.

More about the actual governance review soon.

Sunday, June 17, 2007

Organising biology students

One of my main desires for my year on the executive of the University of Manchester Students' Union is to motivate life sciences students to participate in everything ranging from societies through the student newspaper to academic course representation. While life sciences is the smallest faculty (around 1 700 undergraduates, compared to the 15 000 undergraduates in the humanities), that should never mean that life sciences students should not take part. Students involved in the union are almost entirely humanities students, and the few students from different faculties who are involved are often involved due to joining social/liberation groups or religious groups (e.g. LGBT or the Islamic society). It is a credit to these groups and societies that they are able to encourage their members to take an active role in the political process, and they do significant work to inform and educate those (myself included) who are not as intimately aware of the problems minority students face.

Unfortunately, the involvement of biology students is by and large just for this reason. Few life sciences students attend general meetings and the two positions reserved for life sciences students in our most recent elections were both uncontested. I believe the answer to why there is lack of participation is clear - a failure to communicate the relevancy and importance of the students' union. It is slightly ironic considering the huge role biology is increasingly playing in the public sphere, with genetic modification, stem cells and conservation in particular being critical issues where informed biologists should take part in shaping the public debate. I see three pillars which need to be addressed: general meetings, academic representation, and the life sciences society.

The first impression many get of the union is the general meeting: a rather intimidating event which can leave many frustrated at the lack of ownership they feel. If general meetings are to be useful they must work on a principle where any student is able to stand up and contribute. Technically they are able to do so, but arguing politics in front of a huge partisan audience does not lead to good decision-making. The way general meetings are run has to be reviewed and if there is no satisfactory way to run them ensuring a participatory atmosphere they must be scrapped.

Another pillar which needs reviewing is the committee structure of academic representation. Course representatives either do not attend, they do not contribute to the meeting, or they believe (normally incorrectly) their own personal experience is the experience of everyone on their course. Not attending, without a good reason, is letting down the students on the course. It is not just students who are disappointed by this, but the academic staff who value student feedback. Cutbacks driven by University administration at Gilbert HQ mean that the number of academics who are here for the students are dwindling - students must take advantage while they can. Lack of participation from representatives, and representatives who participate without consulting their peers are also hurting the important work they should be doing. They may give false impressions which can exacerbate the problem. Good training at the outset so course representatives are aware of how fundamental the union is to their work will help.

The final pillar, and the one with most potential, is the faculty of life sciences society. At the moment it is purely a social society, which organises a few events each year. While this is no bad thing, as the society is based around a common degree, it can and should take a more unified approach to university life - ideally, the society should be a mini-union. There are many good projects run by students within the faculty, such as the peer-assisted study scheme, the social events, life sciences sports teams, and the academic representation. All four, to different extents, have not grabbed the awareness and interest of life sciences students. Organising these into a single holistic umbrella will encourage fuller participation, the services provided will be better, and will be for the benefit of all.

In conclusion, there are three main issues which need to be tackled in order for life sciences students to take ownership of their union and their university. The initial impression life sciences get of the union is the general meeting, which is frequently hostile and intimidating. This has a knock-on effect leading to apathy in union involvement from life sciences students. The second is the academic representation structure. Many course representatives are not sufficiently informed and do not communicate with their peers, which is to the detriment of both students and academics alike. The third issue is the life sciences society. It has not reached its potential as a society with 1 700 potential members with a wide range of interests. Hosting events is not enough.

The fortunate thing is, all three pillars can be changed.

Sunday, May 27, 2007

Papers please!

More authoritarian nonsense, this time giving the police the power to harass anyone they don't like the look of, whether or not the police officer has a reasonable suspicion that a crime has been committed! If the person objects to being harassed, it's a £5000 fine due to "obstructing" the police!

Has the government got any ideas about dealing with crime which actually address the problem, which is a lack of social cohesion between communities, a failing education system, and a discredited foreign policy? Whatever happened to tough on the causes of crime?

Tuesday, May 22, 2007

Labour-Tory coalition in Bristol

As it turns out there will be a Labour executive propped up by the Tories in Bristol - one of the suggestions I made previously. Labour and the Tories previously combined to oppose a minority Lib Dem administration continuing in office after we lost two seats. It's interesting that this new coalition is entirely Labour (the article tallies up the number of councillors wrongly, I blame the Labour executive edit: it's correct now), so I imagine the Labour group will have given some concessions to the Tories.

I think this is good for both the Lib Dems and the citizens of Bristol. Firstly, the new executive has the support of a majority of councillors so it cannot be sabotaged by the opposition doing political deals - if it fails it will be due the Tories and Labour failing to work together, and given the current direction both parties are going that should not be a problem. The Liberal Democrats will be able to offer constructive criticism and will be properly able to hold the executive to account.

We should take pride in how we've turned Bristol around this past few years - especially the dramatic improvement in school GCSE results and the huge increase in recycling rates. Though a Labour/Tory coalition may lead back to the years of neglect before the Lib Dems took power a few years ago, it will not be from a lack of scrutiny - we've set the bar high and the Labour/Tory coalition will be hard-pressed to continue at the high standards Bristol's citizens now expect.

Sunday, May 20, 2007

Scrap LDYS's policy committee

I fail to see why LDYS needs a policy committee. Its members are volunteers doing the job in their spare time, and they don't receive any special training - in other words they are just regular party members with a fancy title.

When committees are created they disenfranchise normal members. They take the power of things away from the people and give them to a minority of interested people (who often have an agenda). It discourages people from getting involved - they are instead encouraged to rely on others to handle their issues for them. They might not formally do this, but it is a matter of perception. If a committee is formed to handle an issue, it gives the impression that only the committee members are the appropriate people to handle the issue. It means people avoid taking ownership of LDYS's policy by delegating: "that's up to the policy committee to do".

Committees do have their uses. For a volunteer group, as LDYS's policy committee is, those advantages do not exist. A policy committee does not determine the governance of the organisation, it doesn't manage anything, and it doesn't really coordinate anything. The only thing a policy committee should do is research issues and report on them - and as a volunteer group of five or so people our policy committee does not exactly have the resources to do such a thing. Ad hoc working groups with funds would be appropriate. A standing policy committee with no resources is a pointless exercise in bureaucracy.

If LDYS sees part of its role as ensuring that the Liberal Democrats include the wishes of young people in their manifesto, then it must have an open and effective way to do so. It should encourage all party members to write policies of their own andto discuss them amongst all party members. LDYS members come from all walks of life and encouraging them not just to come forward with their own policies but to debate and discuss other members' policies will be far more beneficial to the organisation. Scrap the policy committee and get members taking ownership of their suggestions.

Thursday, May 17, 2007

Well that wasn't very exciting

Brown's the next Prime Minister then. Congratulations I suppose. What's the point of Tony Blair hanging on for another 6 weeks then? Say what you like about there not being a general election when Thatcher was booted out, but at least the Tories had a contested leadership election back in 1990, albeit one by MPs only.

The Lib Dems have always ensured that our leader was democratically elected, with one person, one vote, since 1976. The Tories' system of MPs choosing two candidates for the party membership to vote on, and Labour's system of allowing people extra votes depending on how many trade unions they've joined (the more you pay, the more influence you've got!), are unfair systems and anti-democracy. If you think that society only works if each person is an equal stakeholder, then the Liberal Democrats are the party to support.

Sunday, May 13, 2007

Most dangerous Home Secretary ever?

Thankfully John Reid's going soon. He recently gave a keynote speech in Venice attempting to convince his equivalent colleagues across Europe to change individual human rights law into some kind of system where only the State has the right to exist, to protect itself against oppression, to a fair trial (or even a trial). Is he the most dangerous Home Secretary ever? Hat tip and interesting commentary from Tom.

Sunday, May 06, 2007

It's time for a coalition in Bristol

Despite some rather optimistic press releases from the Bristol Lib Dems recently about our chances of taking control of the city, we lost two seats including the executive member for social services, and already the other Lib Dem councillors have forced out the council leader, Barbara Janke. Now we're down to 31 seats out of 70, so it's time for some self-reflection. Can we really hold on as a minority administration? I don't think so, and nor should we (I think Norfolk Blogger agrees). While Labour and the Tories on Bristol City Council could team up and defeat us before the elections, they can do so more effectively now. Should we allow them to scupper our flagship policies, watering down motions and then forcing us to take the hit from how unpopular those are? If we continue running minority administrations we will continue to lose council seats each year until we aren't in charge any more, and it will be a long time until the electorate trust us again - even though the failings of the council would be engineered by the opposition.

We're in an uncomfortable place. The Tories and Labour will obviously prefer the status quo of a weakened Lib Dem administration for them to criticise for another year. The Lib Dem group should not let that happen by refusing to run a minority administration, instead going into coalition with either the Tories or Labour or letting the Tories and Labour run a coalition of their own. This would be much better for all parties and especially the residents. The Lib Dems will be the largest party on the council with the most influence, and will not have their policies destroyed by the combined Tory/Labour group and look bad because of it. Whichever group goes into coalition will be able to demonstrate what they will do with power in Bristol, and the third group will form the opposition which would actually start constructive criticism rather than dodgy dealings with the other opposition party to make the Lib Dems look bad.

Constructive criticism rather than politicking, and a stable leadership will serve the interests of Bristol's citizens much better than a weak minority administration.

Friday, May 04, 2007

Local elections 07

This year's been a much better year for the Lib Dems in Manchester than 2006, with us holding all the seats where our councillors were up for re-election, and gaining one seat in Chorlton - congratulations Paul Ankers! Lev unfortunately did not get elected in Northenden despite being a wonderful person (with the best campaign slogan). Over in Stockport, where I work, we gained one seat, consolidating our majority there. Chris Walker, another great guy, also narrowly failed to take Brinnington off Labour.

Things did not go well for the Tories as usual in Manchester with them failing to win any council seats, and ended up in third place in the City Centre behind the Lib Dems and Labour. The so-called Tory resurgence is clearly not occurring in Manchester. The Greens also failed to improve their number of councillors in Manchester, remaining to be seen as a protest vote by much of the electorate. The BNP did well in Higher Blackley coming a clear second (but still no where near winning). Respect also remained a protest vote for residents of Rusholme. I'm slightly concerned about the low turnout - down to 16% in places like the city centre. Why aren't people voting?

Back home in Bristol things weren't so happy with the Lib Dems losing two councillors to Labour, including one executive member's ward, leaving the Lib Dems as the largest party but with even less of a lead. The Tories failed to make any gains in Bristol.

Apart from hearing the results from Scotland and Wales, I'm looking forward to seeing how Kate Little and Owen Griffiths do in Fylde and Bradford respectively. They're both paper candidates, but you never know....

Congratulations to all Lib Dems elected and commiserations for those who lost their seats and who narrowly lost out on winning.

Tuesday, April 24, 2007

Sentamu needs a dictionary more than a Bible

Interesting debate on the place of non-believers in modern society in the House of Lords (hat tip and interesting review). John Sentamu comes out with the new religious tactic of trying to define atheism as a religion, but this is my favourite bit:

Twenty-seven years ago I was chaplain to a young offenders remand centre, Latchmere House. Every inmate was asked to declare his religious affiliation, and four young men were registered as having no religion. One Sunday, all the inmates were offered the chance to go to worship. The four young men with no religion declined the offer, while their fellow inmates on the A wing took up the offer. The prison officer, not wanting the four men to remain locked up in their cells, asked them to clean the toilets on the wing. The following Sunday, our four non-religious young men took up the offer to go to worship. The prison officer was puzzled why they had opted in this week. "Why are you going to chapel?" he asked. The four replied, "Sir, we didn't like the 'No Religion' place of worship". Crudely as they put it, those four young men were saying in their naivety that we are all essentially religious.
No they weren't, they didn't like cleaning toilets. What a shocker.

Monday, April 23, 2007

Homoeopathy

Did you know that there are 5 hospitals in the UK run by the NHS exclusively dedicated to homoeopathic "treatment"? What is worse is that a significant proportion of the UK's population (championed by the anachronism which is Charles Windsor) which believe that homoeopathy actually works, despite any supporting evidence. It, along with so-called alternative medicine courses at some universities, are diverting money away from already cash-strapped hospitals and colleges.

Sign the petition to end taxpayer's money going towards this dangerous distraction from medicine that actually works.

"There is no alternative medicine. There is only medicine that works and medicine that doesn't work." -- Richard Dawkins.

Tuesday, April 17, 2007

Blah blah blah: Atheism under attack!

Saturday's Guardian carries an opinion piece from Nicholas Buxton entitled "Face to faith" where he touts out the now-frequent line from organised religions about how atheism is also a religious movement with a dogmatic approach to everything from science to social justice. He starts his piece with this rather extraordinary sentence: "Post-Enlightment critiques of religion have sought to reduce it to a tool of social oppression (Marxism), bad science (Darwinism) or neurosis (Freudianism)."

Yes, there is bad science in the Bible and other religious texts, but if Buxton thinks that biology is the study of how religion is wrong it sounds like he didn't pay attention at school. Biology is the study of life. It is about uncovering the truth about our origins and the way we and other organisms are formed. Scientists report what they find, not what they want to find. If the findings contradict (or support!) the Bible, then that is just the way it is. The point of science is to uncover the truth not to "prove" preconceived notions. Similarly, Marxism is a critique of oppression of workers. Whether it comes from religion or elsewhere is irrelevant to the theory. Say that religious texts contained support the tectonic plate theory, the theory of universal common descent, or proletariat empowerment - and some perhaps do. Would this have any bearing on the general theory of Marxism or that of evolution?

It is not long until the next extraordinary sentence: "A 'religion' is a story we inhabit that makes sense of what would otherwise be nonsense." He also claims that Marxists, Darwinists and Freudians are in this game too. Why do these people who the organised religions put out to attack secularism and atheism always come up with these ridiculous definitions? What dictionary was that definition pulled out of? Enough of the straw men.

He carries on in this vein, but worth mentioning is his claim that "dogmatic - taken for granted and unprovable - assumptions underlie non-religious world views as well". World views like desiring "progress" are apparently dogmatic. On the other hand, perhaps people desire progress because they see where we were 500 years ago with rampant disease, high child mortality rates and a highly restrictive lifestyle, and see where we are now, and believe things can get better? He questions why there will be a better future if we increase our scientific knowledge. Well, it worked for getting rid of rampant disease and high child mortality rates, and it liberated people's lifestyles.

Buxton's argument is centred around a fundamental misunderstanding of faith. Not all faith is the same. We all have faith that our doctor will be able to help us. We believe this because we are aware of the training doctors go through and the regulation by the government to ensure that they are qualified. We don't have to take it on faith - we could ask to see certification of their licence to practice. But we do, because it's so likely they have those qualifications. Confusing this faith with the faith that the world was created by a all-powerful being who has existed forever and knows everything, which is a far more questionable claim, leads to an completely fallacious conclusion that everything we take on faith is equally likely.

Atheism is not a form of religion. It is opposition to accepting ideas at face value, to unquestioning support for authority. It requires extraordinary evidence for extraordinary claims. It is based on scepticism and rationality.

The ending is worth quoting for entertainment value:

To be a Christian in such circumstances is to be unconventional and nonconformist: it is to be something of a freethinker, espousing a radical vision of human flourishing that shows us how we can be more than what we are, rather than reducing us to less than what we should be.

Saturday, April 14, 2007

More on faith schools

Just thought a certain comment our Dear Leader made about education just about sums up how disastrously wrong New Labour's focus is on this matter. So much for education, education, education. Schools are not meant to be "popular with parents", they have a duty to the children. But on the other hand, children can't vote, so what's the point in making schools work?

Tony Blair and the schools minister Lord Adonis believe strongly that faith schools are popular with parents and want faith groups to be more involved in state education to provide a "distinctive ethos", through privately sponsoring city academies or backing the new breed of "trust schools".